Medical emergency? Call 911. After hours, call your office, our answering service reaches the on-call provider.

Pink Eye vs Allergies: Know the Difference

Pink Eye vs Allergies: Know the Difference

Your child wakes up with red, watery eyes. Is it pink eye, or is it allergies? The two can look a lot alike, and in San Antonio, where cedar pollen hangs in the air in winter and other pollens arrive in spring, the question comes up often. Knowing the difference helps you decide whether your child can go to school, whether they need to be seen and how to make them comfortable.

What is pink eye?

Pink eye, also called conjunctivitis, is swelling of the thin, clear layer that covers the white of the eye and the inside of the eyelids. It has three main causes:

  • Viruses: the most common cause. It often comes with a cold and spreads easily.
  • Bacteria: also spreads easily, and is common in young children.
  • Allergies: caused by pollen, pet dander, dust mites or mold. It does not spread from person to person.

So allergies can actually cause a kind of pink eye. The real question for parents is usually whether the redness is from an infection or from an allergy.

Clues that point to infection

  • It often starts in one eye and may spread to the other a day or two later.
  • Thick yellow or green discharge, with eyelids crusted shut in the morning, suggests bacteria.
  • Watery discharge with a cold, sore throat or fever suggests a virus.
  • The eye feels gritty or sore more than itchy.
  • Someone else at home, school or daycare has had pink eye.

Clues that point to allergies

  • Itching is the big one. Allergy eyes itch, and children rub them a lot.
  • Both eyes are usually affected at the same time.
  • Discharge is clear and watery, not thick.
  • Your child also sneezes, has a runny or itchy nose or has puffy eyelids.
  • Symptoms show up at the same time each year, after playing outside or around a pet.
  • There is no fever.

How to help at home

For any kind of red eye:

  • Gently wipe away discharge with a clean, warm, wet cloth, from the inner corner outward. Use a fresh cloth for each eye.
  • Wash hands often, and wash your child's hands too. Do not share towels, pillows or washcloths.
  • Keep your child from rubbing their eyes as much as possible.

For allergies, cool compresses can calm itching. After time outdoors, have your child wash their face and hands and change clothes, and keep windows closed on high-pollen days. Ask your pediatrician or pharmacist before using allergy eye drops or allergy medicine, and for the right dose for your child's age and weight.

Bacterial pink eye may need prescription antibiotic drops or ointment. Viral pink eye usually clears up on its own in one to two weeks, and antibiotics will not help it. Schools and daycares have their own rules about pink eye, so check with yours about when your child can return.

Learn more at HealthyChildren.org and MedlinePlus.

When to call us

Call your A thru Z Pediatrics office if your child:

  • Is a newborn with red eyes or any eye discharge (call right away)
  • Has thick yellow or green discharge
  • Has eye pain, trouble seeing or is very bothered by light
  • Has redness and swelling of the eyelid or skin around the eye, especially with fever
  • Wears contact lenses and has a red eye (they should stop wearing lenses until checked)
  • Is not getting better after a few days, or has allergy symptoms that get in the way of sleep or school

Go to the ER or call 911 for an eye injury, a chemical splashed in the eye (rinse with water right away and call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222) or swelling around the eye with a high fever and a child who seems very ill.

If your child needs to be seen, request a visit online.

This article is general information, not medical advice. If you have concerns about your child's health, call your A thru Z Pediatrics office.

Common questions

What is pink eye?

Pink eye, also called conjunctivitis, is swelling of the thin, clear layer that covers the white of the eye and the inside of the eyelids.

What causes pink eye in children?

Pink eye has three main causes: viruses, bacteria and allergies. Viruses are the most common cause.

How can I tell if red eyes are allergies or an infection?

Itching, both eyes being affected at once, clear watery discharge, sneezing and no fever point to allergies. Infection often starts in one eye, with thick yellow or green discharge or a gritty, sore feeling.

Is allergy pink eye contagious?

No. Pink eye caused by allergies does not spread from person to person, while viral and bacterial pink eye spread easily.

How long does viral pink eye last?

Viral pink eye usually clears up on its own in one to two weeks. Antibiotics will not help it.